When you think of the best milkshakes in SoHo, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer immediately comes to mind. As a food writer who has explored every nook and cranny of SoHo’s burger and dessert scene, I can confidently say that Black Tap’s milkshakes are a standout in New York City. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these milkshakes are more than a dessert—they’re an experience that combines bold flavors, artistic presentation, and a touch of nostalgia that will leave you craving more. Let’s dive into what makes these milkshakes the best in SoHo and why you absolutely need to try them.
Why Black Tap is Known for SoHo’s Best Milkshakes
Located on 529 Broome Street in SoHo, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has earned a reputation for its elaborate CrazyShake® milkshakes that tower above the glass with decadent toppings. While the restaurant is also known for its mouth-watering burgers and vibrant atmosphere, it’s the milkshakes that consistently steal the show. These shakes are no ordinary treat—they’re designed to wow, both visually and in flavor, and Black Tap has mastered the art of turning a milkshake into a social media phenomenon.
The Iconic CrazyShake® Milkshakes
Black Tap’s CrazyShake® milkshakes are nothing short of iconic, and for good reason. Each shake starts with a rich, creamy base that is then topped with an array of sweets, transforming the milkshake into a towering dessert. Here are a few signature shakes that make Black Tap the go-to spot for milkshake lovers in SoHo:
- The Cotton Candy Shake: One of the most popular shakes on the menu, this one combines a strawberry shake with a vanilla-frosted rim covered in blue, pink, and pearl chocolates. The shake is then topped with whipped cream, a fluffy cloud of cotton candy, a pink lollipop, and a sprinkle of rock candy. It’s whimsical, it’s colorful, and it’s absolutely delicious.
- The Cookie Shake: For cookie lovers, this shake is a dream come true. A vanilla cookie shake with a vanilla-frosted rim covered in cookie crumbles, this treat is topped with an actual “cookiewich” (a giant ice cream sandwich), chocolate chips, crumbled cookies, whipped cream, and a drizzle of chocolate syrup. It’s a dessert within a dessert that’s as tasty as it is photogenic.
- The Sweet N’ Salty Shake: For those who love the combination of sweet and salty, this peanut butter shake hits all the right notes. It features a chocolate-frosted rim decorated with chocolate gems and peanut butter cups, topped with a Sugar Daddy, pretzel rods, chocolate-covered pretzel, whipped cream, and chocolate syrup. It’s a delicious twist on the classic peanut butter and chocolate combination.
- The Sour Power Shake: A perfect choice for those who love a bit of tang, the Sour Power shake combines a black cherry shake with a vanilla-frosted rim covered in sour gummy poppers. The shake is topped with a rainbow pop, giant Pixy Stix, whipped cream, and a sprinkling of Nerds, creating a sour-sweet combination that’s both nostalgic and unique.
What Makes Black Tap’s Milkshakes Stand Out?
Aside from the spectacular presentation, what makes Black Tap’s milkshakes truly special is the quality of ingredients. Each shake starts with premium ice cream that’s blended to create a thick, creamy texture. From there, the shakes are meticulously decorated by hand, ensuring that every milkshake looks like a work of art. The attention to detail doesn’t stop at the toppings, either. Black Tap’s shakes are made to taste as good as they look, which is why they’re considered the best milkshakes in SoHo Black Tap has to offer.
Beyond the Milkshake: The Black Tap Experience
Black Tap’s atmosphere plays a huge role in making the milkshake experience memorable. The SoHo location combines New York’s cool, urban vibe with a laid-back atmosphere that’s perfect for any occasion, whether you’re grabbing a quick shake or enjoying a full meal with friends. With its neon signs, upbeat music, and friendly staff, Black Tap creates an environment that’s fun and Instagram-worthy, making it a favorite hangout spot for people of all ages.
Perfect Pairings: Milkshakes and More
Although the milkshakes are the stars of the show, Black Tap’s menu offers plenty of other delicious options to satisfy your cravings. The burgers here are award-winning, with options like the All-American Burger, the Mexico City Burger, and the vegan-friendly Black Bean Burger. These burgers are the perfect complement to the sweet and decadent milkshakes, creating a balanced meal that’s both satisfying and indulgent.
For those looking for lighter options, Black Tap also offers a variety of salads, wings, and sides, such as their signature fries. The combination of savory dishes and sweet milkshakes makes Black Tap a versatile dining destination where everyone can find something they love.
A Treat for Tourists and Locals Alike
Black Tap’s CrazyShake® milkshakes have earned international fame, attracting tourists from all over the world who come to SoHo specifically to try them. However, these milkshakes are just as popular among locals who crave a unique dessert experience that combines nostalgia with creativity. Whether you’re a New Yorker or a visitor, Black Tap’s milkshakes are an essential part of the SoHo dining experience.
The Social Media Phenomenon
One of the reasons Black Tap’s milkshakes have become so famous is their photogenic appeal. These milkshakes are designed to be shared on social media, with vibrant colors, towering toppings, and a whimsical presentation that’s perfect for Instagram. In fact, Black Tap’s CrazyShake® milkshakes have become so popular on social media that they’ve inspired a worldwide trend, with countless imitations popping up in dessert shops around the globe. However, there’s nothing quite like the original, and Black Tap remains the ultimate destination for anyone seeking the best milkshakes in SoHo Black Tap is known for.
Why You Need to Visit Black Tap for SoHo’s Best Milkshakes
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer offers a one-of-a-kind milkshake experience that’s unlike anything else in SoHo. From the high-quality ingredients to the creative toppings, every aspect of these milkshakes is designed to wow. Whether you’re looking for a sweet treat to share with friends, a fun way to celebrate a special occasion, or simply the best milkshake in SoHo, Black Tap is the place to go.
In a neighborhood known for its culinary diversity and trendsetting eateries, Black Tap has managed to stand out by offering a product that’s as innovative as it is delicious. Their milkshakes are not just desserts—they’re masterpieces that showcase the perfect blend of flavor, creativity, and artistry. If you’re a dessert lover, Black Tap is a must-visit destination that promises an unforgettable experience.